Thieving Guide: Targets & Lockpicks

Plan Melvor Idle 2 thieving with target levels, loot uses, lockpick checks, food safety, shop upgrades, and safe offline training.

Thieving in Melvor Idle 2 is a gathering skill unlocked by reaching Cooking level 10. You pickpocket NPCs and stalls, open locked chests, and work through multi-stage heists. It is not a free money button: a failed attempt can damage and stun your character, and death can cost equipment. Treat success chance, failure damage, food supply, and rewards as one package. The demo build has 20 playable thieving actions, with 20 more locked and progression capped at level 60.

Core Melvor Idle 2 Thieving Rules

The thieving target list divides actions into Lowtown District, Seashade Port, Farmers Market, Mage Tower, Bandit Encampment, and Capital Marketplace. Playable targets include Citizen at level 1 and Thug at level 5. Locked examples include Miner, Carpenter, Gem Stall, Palace Guard, and Chieftain, so do not plan a full route around every name you see in the database.

Every NPC or stall target checks Stealth against the target’s Perception. If you fail, you take damage and get stunned; if you die, you lose equipment. That makes food part of the training setup, not an optional extra. Equip food and use Auto Eat, then watch actual damage before leaving the character alone. Auto Eat reduces manual eating, but it does not make a bad match-up safe.

Fortune is a separate stat. It increases item reward quantity; it does not improve success chance. A high-Fortune setup can still burn food and die on failed attempts. When you compare targets, look at the target panel’s success chance and failure damage alongside the loot table.

Targets fall into several types:

  • NPCs and stalls use Stealth against Perception.
  • Locked chests need the required lockpicks or a corresponding key.
  • Heists require several successful stages and pay completion rewards at the end.

Check the target panel before committing. A target with a tempting drop table may be a bad training choice if its failure damage is too high for your food supply.

Early Targets: Citizen, Thug, and Thug Chests

Citizen is the level 1 target and gives 7 XP. Its listed products include Stone, Bread, Lemon, and Silver Topaz Ring. It is a low-pressure way to start, but the rewards are modest.

Thug is the level 5 target and gives 9 XP. Its drop pool is much more useful for early progression: Leather Boots, Leather Vambraces, Leather Cowl, Leather Chaps, Leather Body, Copper Defender, Rope, Lockpick, Silver Bar, Silver Topaz Amulet, and Balaclava. That makes Thug a natural step up once you can handle the failure damage.

For the first 20 levels, a locked Thug Chest is listed as the fastest XP method at about 38 XP per hour, while Citizen is the best profit target in that bracket, with no GP rate supplied. Do not treat that XP figure as a no-risk plan. Chest access depends on lockpicks or keys, so the rate only matters when you have the right opener.

If you cannot open the chest yet, stay on Citizen or Thug and bank the materials. Thug supplies leather for Crafting and Lockpick items for chests. Those drops support later training instead of becoming instant junk.

Locked Chests, Keys, and Heists

Locked chests require lockpicks or the corresponding key. Pickpocketing Thug, Thug Chief, and Bandit targets supplies Lockpick items, which makes those targets part of the chest supply chain rather than separate content.

A suitable key can reduce the lockpick requirement. Read its actual effect and slot before relying on it. A key half is not a usable key, and a universal key should not be assumed to work on every chest. If a chest is not opening, check the required opener before blaming the XP rate.

Heists are multi-stage targets. You need several successful stages before the completion reward, so they are not single-click pickpocket actions. Plan for the full sequence and keep the same food and health checks you would use on any other target.

The Chef’s Hat Is Not an Early Freebie

Chef’s Hat improves Cooking proficiency, but Chef is not a harmless early target. The current target data lists Chef at level 30 with Perception 238 and 82 failure damage. Do not chase the hat until your food and healing setup can handle that pressure.

Also, do not compare the hat’s Cooking benefit with plain Cooking training as if the hat were already owned. A fair comparison includes the time and food spent obtaining it, then the amount of Cooking that will actually benefit.

What to Keep From Thieving Loot

Thieving loot feeds several skills. Leather from Crafting Stall targets is the clearest early example because it turns directly into Crafting gear.

Leather itemCrafting levelLeather neededSell value
Leather Vambraces115 GP
Leather Boots316 GP
Leather Cowl5210 GP
Leather Shield72Not listed
Leather Chaps9320 GP
Leather Body11426 GP

Keep leather when you still need Crafting levels or gear. If you have spare pieces, Leather Body and Leather Chaps are the strongest listed sell values among the leather armor drops.

Craftsman targets yield Clay, Molten Glass, Pack of Vials, Bowstring, and String. Bowstring sells for 3 GP, but it is also a Fletching input for Normal Bow at level 1, Iron Crossbow at level 13, Oak Bow at level 15, Steel Crossbow at level 29, and Willow Bow at level 30. Molten Glass is used for Unpowered Orb at level 5 Crafting with 3 Molten Glass and Pack of Vials at level 10 Crafting with 2 Molten Glass.

Wool comes from the Crafting Stall and locked Ranchers Chest. It is used for Climbing Rope at level 12 Crafting with 2 Wool and for basic wizard gear across Runecrafting levels 1, 3, 5, and 7. Keep Wool if you plan to train either skill.

Wizard Scholar targets drop Air Rune, Water Rune, Mind Rune, Chaos Rune, and Water Wand. Air Rune is used for Air Wand at level 1 Runecrafting with 12 Air Rune and Air Staff at level 25 Runecrafting with 16 Air Rune. Water Rune is used for Water Wand at level 5 Runecrafting with 12 Water Rune and Water Staff at level 27 Runecrafting with 16 Water Rune. Water Wand sells for 62 GP.

Cooking Stall yields Wheat, Bread, Flour, Milk, Cheese, and Raw Chicken. Fisherman targets drop Basic Bait, Raw Salmon, and Raw Lobster; Raw Salmon sells for 65 GP and Raw Lobster sells for 80 GP. Market Seed Stall drops Potato Seed, Onion Seed, Cabbage Seed, and Strawberry Seed for Farming. Check future recipes before clearing these from the bank.

Shop Upgrades Worth Planning For

The general store offers inventory expansions and location distractions for thieving. Bank space matters because thieving produces many different item types and materials.

  • +20 Bank Slots costs 5,000 GP and requires level 20 Thieving.
  • +25 Bank Slots costs 25,000 GP and requires level 50 Thieving.
  • +30 Bank Slots is demo locked.

Distractions are optional purchases with their own material costs. Compare the actual effect and the material cost before spending. A distraction that consumes rare runes may be worse than direct training if you still need those runes for magic.

Notable examples:

  • Pebble Sling costs 50 Stone, 1 Bowstring, and 30 String, and requires level 15 Ranged.
  • Gold Rings on a String costs 5 Gold Topaz Ring and 150 String.
  • Slime Getaway costs 200 Slime.
  • Bait Scattering costs 500 Basic Bait.
  • Flying Books costs 750 Air Rune and 750 Body Rune, and requires level 40 Runecrafting.
  • Unstable Elements costs 10 Air Battlestaff, 10 Water Battlestaff, 10 Earth Battlestaff, and 10 Fire Battlestaff.
  • Bee Free costs 100 Honey and 100 Beeswax, and requires level 30 Ranching.
  • Fake Arrows costs 1,000 Headless Arrows and 500 Charcoal, and requires level 55 Fletching.
  • Rare Find costs 1 Gold Nugget.

Many advanced shop options are demo locked, including Rune Marbles, Misdirection, Narrow Getaway, Tainted Wine, Stinky Fertiliser, Rotten Fish Panic, and the +30 Bank Slots upgrade. Do not build a training plan around those until they are available in your build.

Safe Training Routine

Before a long session, choose a target whose success chance you can tolerate, equip food, and confirm your Auto Eat threshold. Then watch a few attempts. If failed attempts cause damage and a stun faster than your food and healing can cover, lower the risk or train a safer target.

For offline training, observe enough attempts to estimate damage and food consumption on your loadout. Then leave a food buffer that covers a bad streak. If you cannot survive several failures in a row, do not leave the character unattended.

Use the target panel instead of judging by GP per hour alone. A profitable target with lethal failure damage is not profitable if you die and lose equipment. The same rule applies to locked chests: check the opener, the failure damage, and the food cost before treating the chest as efficient XP.

Common mistakes to avoid:

  • Chasing Chef’s Hat before your food and healing setup can handle level 30 Chef.
  • Assuming Fortune improves success chance when it only affects reward quantity.
  • Assuming every key works on every chest.
  • Selling Bowstring, Wool, Molten Glass, or seeds before checking Crafting, Fletching, Runecrafting, or Farming recipes.
  • Leaving thieving unattended before confirming that Auto Eat can keep up with failure damage.

If you want to stop at a target level, set the level stop condition before logging off so the session does not overshoot your plan. When you return, check the target, the food left in the bank, and the materials you gained before choosing the next goal.

FAQ

How do you unlock thieving in Melvor Idle 2?

Reach Cooking level 10. Thieving then becomes available as a gathering skill.

Does Fortune improve thieving success chance?

No. Fortune increases item reward quantity. Success still depends on Stealth against the target’s Perception.

Can you die while thieving?

Yes. Failed attempts cause damage and a stun, and a character can die and lose equipment. Keep food equipped and watch your health during risky targets.

Where do lockpicks come from?

Pickpocketing Thug, Thug Chief, and Bandit targets supplies Lockpick items. Those lockpicks support locked chest attempts, along with the corresponding keys when available.

Is the locked Thug Chest the best early target?

It is listed at about 38 XP per hour for the first 20 levels, but it requires the right lockpicks or key. Citizen is the best profit target in that bracket, and Thug is the practical step up once you can handle its failure damage. Use the chest only when you have the opener and enough food.