Thieving Money: Chests vs Chickens
Compare Melvor Idle 2 thieving money routes, drop values, bank upgrades, and the unverified Giant Chicken vs stealing chest question.
Melvor Idle 2 thieving money making is mostly about repeatable pickpocketing and what you do with the loot. In the demo build, the reliable early loop is to train on low-level targets, bank the sellable drops, and spend only on thieving upgrades that solve a real problem. The current demo data does not list Giant Chicken as a thieving target or a separate stealing chest as a profit action, so a Giant Chicken vs stealing chest comparison cannot be treated as verified. Use the supported target values below and avoid building an early economy around either one.
What the demo actually supports
The demo build has 40 thieving actions in its database: 20 playable actions and 20 locked actions. Character progression stops at level 60 in the demo, while Early Access raises the cap to 99 and expands the game to 25 skills. That level cap matters for money making because it limits how far you can push target levels, drop tables, and shop upgrades before you are working with incomplete information.
Playable thieving actions are grouped into Lowtown District, Seashade Port, Farmers Market, Mage Tower, Bandit Encampment, and Capital Marketplace. Miner, Carpenter, Gem Stall, Palace Guard, and Chieftain are among the targets still locked in the demo. Do not plan a money route around those names yet.
The early milestone table is thin on profit data. For levels 1–10 and 11–20, Citizen is the named best profit method, but no GP rate is given. A locked Thug Chest entry appears in the fastest-XP column at 38 XP per hour, but it has no GP figure attached. That is not enough to call it a money maker. You can review the demo’s thieving action list and upgrade costs to see which targets and shop items are actually available.
The early thieving money route
Citizen is the level 1 action and gives 7 XP. Its notable products are Stone, Bread, Lemon, and Silver Topaz Ring. Bread is useful as food, while the Silver Topaz Ring is the kind of drop you can sell when bank space gets tight. This is not a big-profit target, but it gets you moving without requiring a higher level.
Thug is the level 5 action and gives 9 XP. Its drop list is much broader: Leather Boots, Leather Vambraces, Leather Cowl, Leather Chaps, Leather Body, Copper Defender, Rope, Lockpick, Silver Bar, Silver Topaz Amulet, and Balaclava. That mix is why Thug is the first practical thieving money stop. You get several items that can be sold, plus materials that feed other skills.
The known sale values for the leather pieces are modest but useful for early cash:
| Leather item | Known sale value |
|---|---|
| Leather Vambraces | 5 GP |
| Leather Boots | 6 GP |
| Leather Cowl | 10 GP |
| Leather Chaps | 20 GP |
| Leather Body | 26 GP |
Selling every leather drop is not automatically correct. Leather is also used in low-level Crafting, so check whether you need the pieces before you clear them out. Still, if you are short on GP and bank space, the leather body and chaps are the highest-value pieces in that group.
At level 20, the +20 Bank Slots upgrade costs 5,000 GP. At level 50, the +25 Bank Slots upgrade costs 25,000 GP. The +30 upgrade is locked in the demo. Bank slots do not generate GP directly, but thieving fills your bank quickly. If overflow is forcing you to stop idling, the 5,000 GP upgrade can pay for itself by preserving drops. The 25,000 GP upgrade is a bigger commitment; buy it when bank pressure is actually costing you loot, not just because it is available.
Which thieving drops are worth keeping
Thieving money in Melvor Idle 2 is not only about raw GP drops. Several targets produce items that are worth more through other skills than through a quick sale. The table below covers the supported drop uses that matter most for early economic decisions.
| Target or source | Notable drops | Known value or use |
|---|---|---|
| Citizen | Stone, Bread, Lemon, Silver Topaz Ring | Bread is food; ring is a sellable drop |
| Thug | Leather gear, Copper Defender, Rope, Lockpick, Silver Bar, Silver Topaz Amulet, Balaclava | Leather pieces sell for 5–26 GP; Lockpick also comes from Thug Chief and Bandit targets |
| Craftsman | Clay, Molten Glass, Pack of Vials, Bowstring, String | Bowstring sells for 3 GP; Molten Glass makes Unpowered Orb at level 5 Crafting with 3, or Pack of Vials at level 10 Crafting with 2 |
| Crafting Stall | Leather, Wool | Leather feeds low-level Crafting; Wool makes Climbing Rope at level 12 Crafting with 2, plus Basic Wizard gear at levels 1, 3, 5, and 7 Runecrafting |
| Wizard Scholar | Air Rune, Water Rune, Mind Rune, Chaos Rune, Water Wand | Water Wand sells for 62 GP; Air Rune makes Air Wand at level 1 Runecrafting with 12, or Air Staff at level 25 with 16; Water Rune makes Water Wand at level 5 with 12, or Water Staff at level 27 with 16 |
| Cooking Stall | Wheat, Bread, Flour, Milk, Cheese, Raw Chicken | Food and cooking inputs, not direct GP |
| Fisherman | Basic Bait, Raw Salmon, Raw Lobster | Raw Salmon sells for 65 GP; Raw Lobster sells for 80 GP |
| Market Seed Stall | Potato Seed, Onion Seed, Cabbage Seed, Strawberry Seed | Farming inputs |
Farmer and Chef targets also matter for food. Farmer drops Potato, Onion, Lettuce, Wheat, Garlic, and Corn. Chef drops Bread, Beef, Chicken Sandwich, Banana Pancake, Strawberry Cake, and Trout Sushi. Those are not high-value cash drops in the same way as a Water Wand or Raw Lobster, but food has a real cost when you are doing combat or idling content. Thieving food can reduce what you spend elsewhere.
How to price a thieving target
Do not copy a GP-per-hour number from another version of the game and assume it applies here. The demo data does not provide per-action times for most targets, and without time per action you cannot turn a drop value into a reliable hourly rate. A target that drops a 62 GP Water Wand is not automatically better than a target that drops 26 GP Leather Bodies unless you know how often each action succeeds and how long it takes.
Use a simple hierarchy instead:
- Known direct GP first. Raw Lobster at 80 GP and Raw Salmon at 65 GP are easy to value. Water Wand at 62 GP is also straightforward. These are the cleanest early comparisons.
- Known sale value plus utility second. Leather Body at 26 GP and Leather Chaps at 20 GP have modest value, but the leather can also feed Crafting. Bowstring at 3 GP is a weak sale, but it feeds several Fletching recipes.
- Skill inputs third. Runes, seeds, Molten Glass, and Wool may not look like money, but they replace purchases or save time in Runecrafting, Farming, Crafting, and Fletching.
- Bank-space cost last. Every kept item competes with future drops. If you are idling overnight, a full bank stops the session. That is why the 5,000 GP bank upgrade can matter more than a slightly better target.
Giant Chicken vs stealing chest: how to judge it
For the specific Melvor Idle 2 Giant Chicken or stealing chest question, the honest answer is that the current demo data does not provide a verified expected return for either. Giant Chicken does not appear in the thieving action list. The closest chest reference is a locked Thug Chest milestone with 38 XP per hour and no GP rate. A separate stealing chest action is not described in the supported action, drop, or shop data. That means any claim that one beats the other for money is unsupported right now.
When either becomes available, compare them on the same five points:
- GP per action from common drops. Use guaranteed or common loot, not a rare item you hope to see.
- Time per action. A high-value drop on a slow action can lose to a low-value drop on a fast one.
- Risk and upkeep. If the target has a distraction, failure state, or food cost, subtract that from the profit.
- Bank-space pressure. A target that fills your bank with low-value junk is worse than its raw GP suggests.
- Level and gear requirements. A target you cannot reach or survive is not a money maker yet.
Until one of those options is exposed with actual drop and timing data, put your time into Citizen, Thug, and the known drop-conversion routes. That is a less exciting answer, but it is the one the current build supports.
Resource costs that eat thieving profit
Thieving has shop upgrades and location distractions, and several of them consume items you could otherwise sell. Pebble Sling costs 50 Stone, 1 Bowstring, and 30 String, and requires level 15 Ranged. Gold Rings on a String costs 5 Gold Topaz Ring and 150 String. Slime Getaway costs 200 Slime. Bait Scattering costs 500 Basic Bait.
Higher-end examples include Flying Books at 750 Air Rune and 750 Body Rune with level 40 Runecrafting, Unstable Elements at 10 of each Air, Water, Earth, and Fire Battlestaff, Bee Free at 100 Honey and 100 Beeswax with level 30 Ranching, Fake Arrows at 1,000 Headless Arrows and 500 Charcoal with level 55 Fletching, and Rare Find at 1 Gold Nugget. Rotten Fish Panic, Stinky Fertiliser, Tainted Wine, Rune Marbles, Misdirection, and Narrow Getaway are locked in the demo.
Those are costs, not profit. Do not buy a distraction just because it is listed. If the item cost is higher than the extra GP or drops it enables, skip it. The same rule applies to bank slots: a 25,000 GP purchase at level 50 is a real setback if you are still building food, gear, or skill inputs.
A practical level 1–60 plan
Use this sequence if you want a clean thieving money start without relying on unverified targets:
- Levels 1–4: Citizen. Bank Bread for food, keep the Silver Topaz Ring, and sell duplicates only when bank space is tight.
- Levels 5–19: Thug. This is your first broad loot target. Keep Lockpick, bank silver items, and sell duplicate leather pieces when you need GP.
- Level 20: buy +20 Bank Slots for 5,000 GP if overflow is a problem. Do not buy it automatically if you are still saving for something more important.
- Levels 20–49: rotate among unlocked targets. Use Fisherman for Raw Salmon and Raw Lobster GP, Wizard Scholar for runes and Water Wand value, and Cooking Stall or Farmer for food. Check locked targets before assuming they exist.
- Level 50: consider +25 Bank Slots for 25,000 GP. This is best when you are idling long sessions and losing drops to a full bank.
- Level 60: demo cap. Stop planning around level 99 gear or late-game thieving uniques in the demo. Early Access expands the cap, but the demo does not give you that content yet.
Common mistakes
Selling Bowstring at 3 GP and then buying Fletching materials is a bad trade. Bowstring is used in Normal Bow at level 1 Fletching, Iron Crossbow at level 13, Oak Bow at level 15, Willow Bow at level 30, and Steel Crossbow at level 29. Keep a stack if you plan to train Fletching.
Treating leather as junk is another early mistake. Leather Body sells for 26 GP and Leather Chaps for 20 GP, but both also feed low-level Crafting. Sell extras, not your entire supply.
Chasing Giant Chicken or a stealing chest without drop data is a third mistake. The current build does not support a profit comparison, so spending time on either is a gamble, not a plan. Stick to targets with known products and known sale values.
Finally, do not ignore the level 60 demo cap. A route that looks strong at level 80 or 99 may be locked, incomplete, or simply unavailable. Build your early economy around what the demo actually exposes: Citizen, Thug, Fisherman, Wizard Scholar, Crafting Stall, and the bank upgrades that keep those drops flowing.
Related Guides
Calculator Guide: XP, Combat, and Gold
Learn what a Melvor Idle 2 calculator can actually answer, which in-game numbers to feed it, and how to plan skill XP, combat time, and gold per hour.
Money Making: Best Ways to Farm Gold
Build a reliable Melvor Idle 2 money making routine: mine and smith gear to sell, manage food, idle safely, and spend gold on the right upgrades.